Dawn and the Impossible Three
by Ann M. Martin · The Baby-Sitters Club #5
A warm, thoughtful exploration of what happens when a babysitter cares too much — and learns to set boundaries
The story
Dawn Schafer, the newest Baby-Sitters Club member, takes on the Barrett kids — three children whose recently divorced mother is drowning in disorganization. As Dawn cleans, cooks, and manages increasingly on her own, she must figure out where professional responsibility ends and parental duty begins, all while navigating friendship jealousy within the club.
Age verdict
Best for ages 8-10. Younger readers enjoy the babysitting adventures; older readers appreciate the boundary-setting themes. The brief kidnapping scare resolves quickly and safely.
Our take
A warm, socially intelligent book that serves parents and teachers better than it thrills kids — its real-world emotional complexity and empathy-building power outshine its entertainment quotient.
What stands out
Each audience's top 3 dimensions. Out of 30 scored per book.
Kids love
- Character voice Strong
Triangulated with A Little Princess. Down's voice is distinctive (anxious-organized, California-nostalgic, self-aware). Ensemble voices clear (Kristy, Mary Anne, Buddy). Sits at because internal monologue is consistent and identifiable without tags, though not as psychologically rich as Harriet or emotionally layered as A Little Princess.
- Ending satisfaction Strong
Comparable to Because of Winn-Dixie — Respects both characters and readers. Mrs. Barrett agrees to trial improvement, Kristy solves transport problem, Buddy's call signals recovery. Resolution honors promises without false tidiness. Sits at because hopeful and character-true without wrapping everything in a bow.
Parents love
- Stereotype-breaker Strong
Triangulated with Harriet the Spy. Down subverts "new kid" archetype; Mrs. Barrett challenges "bad divorced mom" stereotype. Remarkably, 12-year-old sets professional boundaries with adult, modeling that children's fairness perspective deserves action. Sits at because stereotype-breaking is consistent and original for 1987.
- Moral reasoning Strong
Comparable to Bridge to Terabithia — When does helping enable? What are limits of professional responsibility? Can children tell adults they're failing as parents? No clean answer—Mrs. Barrett is overwhelmed, not malicious. Resolution requires compromise. Sits at because morally complex without being philosophically dense.
Teachers love
- Empathy & self-awareness Strong
Kristy's jealousy as masked fear, Mrs. Barrett's disorder as grief, Buddy's seeking as response to instability. Down's shame-free acceptance models judgment-free understanding. Sits at because empathy-building is central and systematic.
- Discussion fuel Strong
Was Down right? Is it child's place to confront failing adult? Genuine disagreement possible. Divorce and jealousy add discussion layers. Sits at because strong conversation material without requiring trauma management.
✓ Perfect for
- • readers dealing with divorce in their own families
- • kids who love realistic friendship stories with emotional depth
- • fans of the BSC series exploring Dawn's perspective
- • children ready for stories where kids solve real problems rather than magical ones
Not ideal for
Readers seeking fast-paced adventure, fantasy, or heavy humor will find this book's domestic realism and emotional focus slower than expected.
⚠ Heads up
At a glance
- Pages
- 176
- Chapters
- 15
- Words
- 24k
- Lexile
- 650L
- Difficulty
- Easy
- POV
- First Person
- Illustration
- None
- Published
- 1987
- Publisher
- Scholastic
- ISBN
- 9781338642254
Mood & style
You'll know it worked when…
A child who finishes this book may want to discuss what they'd do as a babysitter, or talk about fairness in adult-child relationships.
If your kid loved "Dawn and the Impossible Three"
Matched across 30 dimensions — interest hooks, character appeal, tone, pacing, emotional core. Not by what other people bought. By what fits the same reader profile.
Mary Anne Saves the Day: A Graphic Novel (The Baby-Sitters Club #3)
by Ann M. Martin (writer), Raina Telgemeier (adapter/illustrator)
Same genre (realistic fiction). Both warm in tone
Magnolia Wu Unfolds It All
by Chanel Miller
Same genre (realistic fiction). Both warm in tone
Ramona's World
by Beverly Cleary
Same genre (realistic fiction). Both warm in tone
Superfudge
by Judy Blume
Same genre (realistic fiction). Both warm in tone
The Vanderbeekers of 141st Street
by Karina Yan Glaser
Same genre (realistic fiction). Both warm in tone
Jasmine Toguchi, Super Sleuth
by Debbi Michiko Florence
Same genre (realistic fiction). Both warm in tone
Want more picks like this?
Get 5 hand-picked book reviews for your child's age — one email a month.